We noticed you're browsing in private or incognito mode.

To continue reading this article, please exit incognito mode or log in.

Not a subscriber? Subscribe now for unlimited access to online articles.

  • Xu Wenkai's painting 404404404 echoes the manual labor required to maintain China's "Great Firewall" by serially repeating the error message that greets visitors to banned webpages.
  • courtesy of the artist
  • Intelligent Machines

    China’s tech boom has inspired a wave of internet-related art

    These artists are critiquing how technology promotes consumerism, shapes identity, and enables new forms of censorship.


    The rise of a distinctive e-commerce culture is among the most striking changes the internet has wrought in China. Over $30 billion in merchandise traded hands on Alibaba platforms alone last November 11, a consumer holiday known as Singles’ Day, which dwarfs the US’s Black Friday. Most of those sales took place on Taobao, Alibaba’s principal consumer-facing website and app. Running on Taobao, a series by Hong Kong artist Mak Ying Tung 2, comprises photographs of oversized treadmills that Mak found on Taobao. She enlarged the stock photographs and embedded stills from movies like Iron Man and Star Wars on the treadmills’ screens to present an absurd and unsettling vision of humanity enslaved to in-app purchases and streaming entertainment. If Taobao has given rise to a new consumerist creed, artists like Mak are articulating a speculative iconography to match.  

    Mak Ying Tung 2, Running on Taobao

    courtesy of de Sarthe Gallery

    Mak uses Marxist theory to analyze the depersonalized, ubiquitous nature of relationships between buyers and sellers on Taobao, which has its own slang lexicon. She says, “Class and the relations of production are hidden behind the rhetoric of the internet.”

    Mak Ying Tung 2, Relics

    courtesy of de Sarthe Gallery

    In Mak’s Relics series, turn-of-the-millennium consumer electronic devices such as the CD Walkman and original Nintendo Game Boy are rendered in the grandiose style of religious icons. In Mak’s view, these once-cherished objects have been transformed into quaint artifacts of a pre-smartphone past—relegated to history’s trash heap.

    Open Sesame, The Real Thing issue

    courtesy of Open Sesame

    One can glimpse the diverse needs that Taobao’s 620 million users sate online by flipping through the inaugural issue of the Beijing magazine Open Sesame, which made a compendium of oddball items sold on Taobao. The goods range from the merely bizarre (a portable, one-person sauna) to the perversely intimate (miniature sex dolls).


    This story is part of our January/February 2019 Issue. See the rest of the issue.

    Anxieties about economic advantage, national security, and censorship tend to dominate the West’s conversation about technology in China. But Chinese artists have a different set of concerns about technology’s ramifications. Shanghai-based artist Miao Ying references censorship in some of her works. But she is less interested in taking a stand against the Chinese government’s regulation of the internet than in highlighting the unique cultural tics that take shape under those strictures. Much of her work deals with her concept of the “Chinternet”—a break with Western norms that supplies fertile ground for new ideas and identities to grow. Fellow Shanghai artist Lu Yang likewise plays with the intersection between technology and identity: her outlandish digital avatars evade categorization along national, racial, or gender lines, and thus afford glimpses of a digital, post-human future. 

    Miao Ying, God, Goddess, and Godfather

    courtesy of the artist

    In this work, Miao pokes fun at the hallowed status that Alibaba founder Jack Ma has attained among Chinese netizens. Entrepreneurs like Ma who have amassed godlike fortunes in the last decade have become cultural icons on Chinese social media, kick-­starting new cults of personality and identity.

    Lu Yang, Delusional Mandala

    courtesy of MadeIn Gallery

    Lu relies on Western streaming services like Vimeo to distribute her work, and she is fond of saying that she lives on the internet. Delusional Mandala is a series in which Lu inserts a 3D-scanned avatar of herself into scenarios that oscillate between sacred and profane, raising compelling questions about the nature of selfhood.

    Lu Yang, Electromagnetic Brainology

    courtesy of the artist

    Lu does not see technology as an end in itself, but as a tool of exploration. “If art comes from life, then there is no way to distinguish current technology and art,” she says. Many of her videos, like 2017’s Electromagnetic Brainology, weave neurology, religion, and pop culture into a hybrid, personalized aesthetic identity.


    A computer scientist by background, Xu Wenkai, who also goes by aaajiao, recently moved from Shanghai to Berlin. He admits to a pessimistic view of how technologies shaped by nationalism in turn affect culture. However, his criticisms are not aimed at China alone. Despite the differences between the ways China and the West absorb new technology, Xu says, we’re all headed the same way: “[China and the West] are at different points on the same time line, but it’s hard to find a reference point to compare these differences. They are each other’s past, as well as each other’s future.” The creative, complex responses to censorship seen in work by Xu and Miao Ying give an early idea of the strange form this future might assume. 

    Miao Ying, Problematic GIFs

    courtesy of MadeIn Gallery

    Miao Ying’s Problematic GIFs comments on tools of censorship as they’re applied to the Chinese social messaging platform WeChat. The error screen that displays when an image fails to load is ironically presented front and center as a non-portrait, obscured by censorship and surrounded by freeze-frames of GIFs popularly used on WeChat.

    aaajiao, GFWlist

    courtesy of the artist

    In this installation, aaajiao hints at what might be the physical length of China’s “Great Firewall”—a sophisticated infrastructure for blocking websites and search terms—by printing out the URLs it restricts. The monotonous, serial repetition echoes the manual labor required to constantly monitor and block sensitive material, the never-­ending work of the government’s internet watchdogs.

    Josh Feola is a Shanghai-based writer and musician, and culture editor of RADII. He tweets @joshfeola.

    Keep up with the latest in intelligent machines at EmTech Digital.

    The Countdown has begun.
    March 25-26, 2019
    San Francisco, CA

    Register now
    courtesy of de Sarthe Gallery
    courtesy of de Sarthe Gallery
    courtesy of de Sarthe Gallery
    courtesy of de Sarthe Gallery
    courtesy of de Sarthe Gallery
    courtesy of de Sarthe Gallery
    courtesy of Open Sesame
    courtesy of Open Sesame
    courtesy of Open Sesame
    courtesy of the artist
    courtesy of MadeIn Gallery
    courtesy of the artist
    courtesy of MadeIn Gallery
    courtesy of the artist
    More from Intelligent Machines

    Artificial intelligence and robots are transforming how we work and live.

    Want more award-winning journalism? Subscribe to Print + All Access Digital.
    • Print + All Access Digital {! insider.prices.print_digital !}*

      {! insider.display.menuOptionsLabel !}

      The best of MIT Technology Review in print and online, plus unlimited access to our online archive, an ad-free web experience, discounts to MIT Technology Review events, and The Download delivered to your email in-box each weekday.

      See details+

      12-month subscription

      Unlimited access to all our daily online news and feature stories

      6 bi-monthly issues of print + digital magazine

      10% discount to MIT Technology Review events

      Access to entire PDF magazine archive dating back to 1899

      Ad-free website experience

      The Download: newsletter delivery each weekday to your inbox

      The MIT Technology Review App

    You've read of three free articles this month. for unlimited online access. You've read of three free articles this month. for unlimited online access. This is your last free article this month. for unlimited online access. You've read all your free articles this month. for unlimited online access. You've read of three free articles this month. for more, or for unlimited online access. for two more free articles, or for unlimited online access.